5 Rules of Great Email Notifications

Brent Sleeper
Feb. 23, 2018 by Brent Sleeper

Email notifications are powerful drivers of user engagement with SaaS apps. But not all of these messages are created equal. The best alerts convey key information and make interaction feel almost effortless, while poorly designed notifications are counterproductive and result in decreased engagement or even customer churn.

I’ve received some really effective notifications. But I’ve received many more lackluster ones. I’m sure you have, too. Some were monospaced, plaintext messages spit out by a process deep in the bowels of an ancient ERP system. Others were so overloaded with competing messages, images, CTAs, and other marketing gizmos that the basic utility of the notification was lost in the noise.

So, when it comes to notifications and similar transactional emails, what differentiates the good, the bad, and the ugly? In other words, what makes a great product email? Our team has looked at lots of real-world examples. Here are our takeaways.

1. The subject line is all-important. Email marketers have made an art and science of writing subject lines that yield high open rates, but remember that notifications are different from most marketing messages. While opening a message is a sign of user engagement, the most effective email notifications are written so that the subject line is the message. Even if a user never opens the alert, she or he should get what’s needed just by reading the subject line.

2. Good notifications convey just one idea. Effective email alerts are highly focused messages and a perfect illustration of when “less is more.” While the email body is an opportunity for some elaboration on the core information conveyed in the subject line, but don’t be tempted to stray from that single idea. Extraneous information or visual clutter muddies the value the of the email and distracts your user from the essential message or call to action. Overloaded notifications quickly get relegated in a user’s head to the category of “useless marketing messages” and are a sure route to disengagement, unsubscribes, and even spam flags.

Example Mint Notification
Mint’s account security notification reinforces user trust with a direct, simple message.

3. Alerts should get straight to the point with a direct call to action. Email notifications are immediate, time-sensitive, and relatively frequent. Your user will give them just a glance—you might earn 5 seconds of their time at best—so it’s not the time for subtlety. Express the facts the user needs to know and provide an obvious way for him or her to take action if needed. Done.

Example LinkedIn Notification
LinkedIn’s re-engagement notification has a good value proposition and clear call to action.

4. Email notifications must be highly personalized. A notification is a nearly perfect example a triggered email. It was sent in response to a specific user action or state. So be sure that the content of the message reflects that unique situation. Being personal doesn’t mean inserting a first name and leaving it at that — every bit of the notification should reinforce the user’s specific context, actions, and needs. In fact, any information that’s not specifically personalized is suspect and something you should consider removing.

5. The best notifications reinforce the user experience. Just because email notifications should be direct and succinct, they don’t need to be blandly utilitarian. In fact, the best ones are full of personality and immediately recognizable as part of the user’s overall experience with an app or service. Through tone, voice, and visual identity, email notifications have a significant impact on a user’s impression of a service or app’s style and brand. They should be designed with as much care as any other aspect of a product’s UX.

Example Product Hunt Notification
Product Hunt’s social notification hits all the right notes.

Email notifications have a major impact on any app or site’s user experience, and they’re among the most important drivers of user engagement, retention, and growth.

What’s your experience with email notifications and other messages? Send us a tweet! We’d love to hear your point of view and the sorts of questions you run into.

Brent

P.S. Want to learn more about building a successful product with email notifications? Our recent product manager’s guide to email provides a great starting point. And when you’re ready to dig even deeper into what makes email messages like these click, check out “Designing Transactional Email to Build Brand” and “Building Trust and Loyalty with Transactional Email.”

 

Related Content

Finally, A Product Manager’s Guide to Email

This guide is a great resource to help product teams succeed with app-generated emails, email notifications and making the most of email in their apps.

read more

Fantastic Product Emails (And Where to Find Them)

An excellent product email can help drive better user engagement with your app. Check out our examples of great product emails that stand out in the inbox.

read more

Don Draper’s User Engagement Advice for Product Teams

Four key lessons for product teams on writing effective emails to drive user engagement from Mad Men’s iconic ad man Don Draper.

read more

Get started and start sending

Try SparkPost and see how easy it is to deliver your app’s email on time and to the inbox.

Try Free

Send this to a friend